Exploring the No-Function-In-Structure principle

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
Although much of past work in AI has focused on compiled knowledge systems, recent research shows renewed interest and advanced efforts both in model-based reasoning and in the integration of this deep knowledge with compiled problem solving structures. Device-based reasoning can only be as good as the model used; if the needed knowledge, correct detail, or proper theoretical background is not accessible, performance deteriorates. Much of the work on model-based reasoning references the ‘no-function-in-structure’ principle, which was introduced by de Kleer and Brown. Although they were well motivated in establishing the guideline, this paper explores the applicability and workability of the concept as a universal principle for model representation. This paper first describes the principle, its intent and the concerns it addresses. It then questions the feasibility and the practicality of the principle as a universal guideline for model representation.

This publication has 5 references indexed in Scilit: