The Two-Edged Sword of Large-Dose Steroids for Spinal Cord Trauma
- 1 October 1993
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Annals of Surgery
- Vol. 218 (4) , 419-427
- https://doi.org/10.1097/00000658-199310000-00003
Abstract
Objective In 1990, large-dose steroid administration was advocated in spine-injured patients to lessen neurologic deficits. The authors undertook both prospective and retrospective studies to evaluate the response of such profound pharmacologic intervention. Summary Background Data Of all sources of nonfatal injury, spinal cord trauma remains the most devastating in both cost and impact on the quality of the patient's life. One study found that routine large-dose steroid administration after injury lessened the extent of neurologic injury. After uncommonly promp‡ and broad lay press publicity, this practice was widely accepted. Biased by knowledge of the known immunosuppressive effects of steroids, the authors suspected that pneumonia was both more frequent and severe in steroid-treated patients. Methods Thirty-two patients with cervical or upper thoracic spinal injuries (C3–6, 20 patients; C6–7, 6 patients; and T1–6 6 patients) were studied at an urban level I trauma center from January 1987 to February 1993. Complete spinal cord injury was present in 22 of 32 patients; 14 patients received steroids postinjury. There was no difference in mean age, cord level, age-adjusted injury severity score, or the percent of injury severity score caused by the spinal injury. Results The length of hospital stay was longer in steroid-treated patients (S) than in nonsteroid (NS) patients, that is, 44.4 days versus 27.7 days, respectively (p = 0.065). Seventy-nine per cent of S patients had pneumonia compared with 50% of NS patients (p = 0.614). There was no statistical difference in the episodes of pneumonia per patient between the two groups (p > 0.05). Prospectively, the authors evaluated sequentially several parameters known to be important in human immune responses to bacterial challenges in nine S and five NS patients. In S patients, both the per cent and density of monocyte class II antigen expression and T-helper/ suppressor cell ratios were lower than in NS patients. However, S patients did have an initially higher, earlier boost in some host defense parameters that rapidly declined, and their subsequent response was both blunted and delayed. These differences became even clearer when stratified according to cord level and incomplete versus complete cord status. Not surprisingly, infected patients, whether S or NS, had lower levels of monocyte antigen expression, CR3, and helper/ suppressor ratios. Conclusions These data do not permit a judgment to be made whether neurologic status was improved by S administration. It is known that vital immune responses were adversely affected, that pneumonia was somewhat more prevalent, and that hospitalization was prolonged and costs therefore increased by an average of $51,504 per admission. Further clinical studies will be needed to determine to what extent these observations offset the putative benefits of large-dose steroids in the treatment of spinal trauma.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Randomized, Controlled Trial of Methylprednisolone or Naloxone in the Treatment of Acute Spinal-Cord InjuryNew England Journal of Medicine, 1990
- Glucocorticoid effects on the production and actions of immune cytokinesJournal of Steroid Biochemistry, 1988
- THE INFLUENCE OF THE PATTERN OF INFLAMMATION AND ADMINISTRATION OF STEROIDS ON CLASS II MHC ANTIGEN EXPRESSION IN RENAL TRANSPLANTSTransplantation, 1986
- REEVALUATION OF T CELL SUBSET MONITORING IN CYCLOSPORINE-TREATED RENAL ALLOGRAFT RECIPIENTSTransplantation, 1985
- Septic Complications of Corticosterojd Administration after Central Nervous System TraumaAnnals of Surgery, 1985
- Glucocorticoid-induced thymocyte apoptosis is associated with endogenous endonuclease activationNature, 1980
- Effects of Corticosteroids on Human Monocyte FunctionJournal of Clinical Investigation, 1974
- Effects of Corticosteroids on Immunity in Man I. DECREASED SERUM IgG CONCENTRATION CAUSED BY 3 OR 5 DAYS OF HIGH DOSES OF METHYLPREDNISOLONEJournal of Clinical Investigation, 1973
- THE NATURE AND THE SPECIFICITY OF MONONUCLEAR CELLS IN EXPERIMENTAL AUTOIMMUNE INFLAMMATIONS AND THE MECHANISMS LEADING TO THEIR ACCUMULATIONThe Journal of Experimental Medicine, 1971
- THE EFFECT OF GLUCOCORTICOSTEROIDS ON THE KINETICS OF MONONUCLEAR PHAGOCYTESThe Journal of Experimental Medicine, 1970