Importance of nonanalog nucleon charge exchange transitions in pion knockout reactions

Complete analog dominance in the nucleon charge exchange transitions affecting ratios of ($\pi , \pi N$) cross sections near the (3,3) resonance is experimentally unfounded. No dramatic jumps with neutron number in neutron removal ratios are now expected. There may be a vestige of analog dominance in the deviation of $\frac{\sigma ({\pi }^{+}, {\pi }^{+}p)}{\sigma \left({\pi }^{+}{\pi }^{0}p\right)}$ from the impulse approximation. Disagreement of an intranuclear cascade calculation with the nucleon charge exchange model (and experiment) is also discussed.