The osteology and relationships ofTetraceratops insignis, the oldest known therapsid

Abstract
Preparation and restudy of the Lower Permian synapsid Tetraceratops insignis demonstrate that it is related more closely to therapsids than to other Permo-Carboniferous synapsids. As the oldest known therapsid and the only known Lower Permian therapsid from North America, Tetraceratops not only fills a large morphological gap between Permo-Carboniferous sphenacodontids and Permian therapsids from Russian and South Africa, but also provides important new insights into the origins of the latter group. Tetraceratops shares with biarmosuchians and other Permo-Triassic therapsids the presence of a broad, concave shelf on the upper margin of the temporal fenestra, a wide tabular, a braincase attached firmly to the cheek, a reduced quadrate, a postero-median flange of the pterygoid, the loss of ectopterygoid teeth, a reduced ventral plate of the epipterygoid excluded from the basicranial articulation, and a shortened interpterygoid vacuity. Tetraceratops possesses several autapomorphies: a long diastema on the maxilla; bony, possibly hornbearing, processes on the premaxilla, prefrontal and angular; and a large orbital contribution of the lacrimal.