A comparison of multilocus sequence typing and fluorescent fragment-length polymorphism analysis genotyping of clone complex and other strains of Neisseria meningitidis
Five National Collection of Type Culture (NCTC) strains and 14 isolates of Neisseria meningitidis , representing 13 outbreak isolates from within the UK, were examined by multilocus sequence typing (MLST) for seven house-keeping genes. The results were compared with those of fluorescent amplified fragment-length polymorphism (FAFLP) analysis. Phylogenetic inferences were made from 3284-nucleotide lengths of sequence for the 19 isolates, by distance and parsimony methods. Two clusters of isolates were delineated. The larger, comprising eight isolates – S1, S3, Ironville, P9, ET-37 (M99-241951), P7, P10 and P60 – shared 100–99.2% similarity and varied in only 40 nucleotides (∼1.22% variation) from the consensus sequence alignment. This cluster could be equated to the ET-37 complex because it had allelic signatures identical to MLST sequence types 11 and 50. These eight isolates were also assigned to one group by FAFLP. The reference ET-5 complex isolate ‘ET-5 (NG144/82)’ and an isolate (X9) from an outbreak in the north of England were also grouped together by MLST. They shared 99.2% similarity and differed within the aro E and fum C genes by 4 and 17 nucleotides, respectively. Their MLST sequence types were 32 and 661 and, therefore, these two isolates could be equated to the ET-5 complex. They also grouped together by FAFLP. A comparison of the resources required to apply MLST to the 19 isolates examined with those needed to characterise them by FAFLP indicated that FAFLP (a fragment-based genotyping method) is more cost-effective than the partial sequencing approach, MLST.