Evaluation of subjective assessment of liver function from radionuclide images
- 1 February 1987
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in The British Journal of Radiology
- Vol. 60 (710) , 127-132
- https://doi.org/10.1259/0007-1285-60-710-127
Abstract
The appearance of non-hepatic uptake in 99Tcm-colloid images is an important indicator of poor liver function. We undertook this study to evaluate the ability of experienced observers to assess liver function from radionuclide images. A simple model was used to simulate the changing distribution of 99Tcm-colloid in the liver, spleen and bone marrow as the liver function and mass were varied. Suitable images of these three organs were isolated from real studies and used as "templates" to create realistic simulated 99Tcm-colloid images, with the count densities of liver, spleen and bone marrow determined by the model. These images were presented in random order to several observers, who were asked to assess liver function. Comparison of the estimated with the true function shows that visual assessment is systematically inaccurate, with underestimation of poor function and overestimation of good function. It is also imprecise, especially for livers with only mildly impaired function. Observers were also affected by changing liver mass and were more likely to judge small livers to be abnormal. We suggest that objective assessment using a quantitative technique should be used an an adjunct to visual inspection for the evaluation of liver function.This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Liver scintiscanning as a screening test in the detection of alcoholic cirrhosisNuclear Medicine Communications, 1986
- COMPARISON OF QUANTITATIVE AND VISUAL DETECTION OF NEW FOCAL BONE-LESIONS1985
- Measurement of liver and spleen volume by computed tomography. Assessment of reproducibility and changes found following a selective distal splenorenal shunt.Radiology, 1981
- Scintigraphic diagnosis of cirrhosis: a receiver operator characteristic analysis of the common interpretative criteria.Radiology, 1981
- A COMPARISON OF 4 STANDARD SCINTIGRAPHIC TV DISPLAYS - CONCISE COMMUNICATION1980
- SIMPLE COMPUTER QUANTITATION OF SPLEEN-TO-LIVER RATIOS IN THE DIAGNOSIS OF HEPATOCELLULAR DISEASE1979
- Spleen Blood Flow and Splanchnic Haemodynamics in Blood Dyscrasia and other SplenomegaliesClinical Science, 1970
- Variations in Hepatic Blood Flow in Man during Health and DiseaseNew England Journal of Medicine, 1949