Tricritical behavior of the Ising antiferromagnet with next-nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic interactions: Mean-field-like tricritical exponents?

Abstract
The tricritical behavior of a model studied by Harbus and Stanley is reanalyzed. The Harbus-Stanley analysis of the direct susceptibility suggested anomalous (i.e., non-mean-field-like) tricritical exponents. The tricritical point cannot be unambiguously located by present series data. We point out that, if the true tricritical temperature were actually somewhat lower than the Harbus-Stanley value, then standard ratio analysis would give tricritical exponents consistent with the Gaussian-tricritical-fixed-point analysis of Riedel and Wegner. However, the present situation remains inconclusive.