Connectionist Models of Orientation Identification

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
We have used connectionist simulations in an attempt to understand how orientation tuned units similar to those found in the visual cortex can be used to perform psychophysical tasks involving absolute identification of stimulus orientation. In one task, the observer (or the network) was trained to identify which of two possible orientations had been presented, whereas in a second task there were 10 possible orientations that had to be identified. By determining asymptotic performance levels with stimuli separated to different extents it is possible to generate a psychophysical function relating identification performance to stimulus separation. Comparisons between the performance functions of neural networks with those found for human subjects performing equivalent tasks led us to the following conclusions. Firstly, we found that the ‘psychometric functions’ generated for the networks could accurately mimic the performance of the human observers. Secondly, the most important orientation selective units in such tasks are not the most active ones (as is often assumed). Rather, the most important units were those selective for orientations offset 15° to 20° to either side of the test stimuli. Such data reinforce recent psychophysical and neurophysiological data suggesting that orientation coding in the visual cortex should be thought of in terms of distributed coding. Finally, if the same set of input units was used in the two-orientation and the 10-orientation situation, it became apparent that in order to explain the difference in performance in the two cases it was necessary to use either a network without hidden units or one with a very small number of such units. If more hidden units were available, performance in the 10-orientation case was found to be too good to fit the human data. Such results cast doubt on the hypothesis that hidden units need to be trained in order to account for simple perceptual learning in humans.