Unions on the Margin?
- 1 May 1990
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Employee Relations
- Vol. 12 (5) , 2-24
- https://doi.org/10.1108/01425459010003105
Abstract
Discussions about the position of British trade unions under Thatcherism continue to interest scholars and practitioners in the UK, and a variety of theories have been put forward which suggest that unions are becoming increasingly marginal to workplace employee relations. Three of these are focused on, namely, the roll‐back of union organisation, the separation of collective bargaining from strategic decision making, and the impact of employee involvement on union activity. These ideas are evaluated against data from a longitudinal study of four multi‐plant private sector organisations, each of which has high levels of union density and some forms of employee involvement. The data, which were collected in the late 1980s, suggest that simple monocausal correlations – such as employee involvement is directly undermining trade unions – are not robust enough to cope with the reality of organisational life. Much more credence needs to be given to the environmental and more broader managerial context within which employee relations takes place.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- THE JAPANISATION OF BRITISH INDUSTRY? A CASE STUDY OF QUALITY CIRCLES IN THE CARPET INDUSTRYEmployee Relations, 1988
- Employee Relations Strategy In The Multi‐Divisional CompanyPersonnel Review, 1988
- BARGAINING WITHIN THE ENTERPRISE: CENTRALIZED OR DECENTRALIZED?Journal of Management Studies, 1987
- MANAGERIAL STRATEGY AND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS: A CASE STUDY OF PLANT RELOCATIONJournal of Management Studies, 1986
- Patterns of Industrial Relations ManagementEmployee Relations, 1986
- Changing management strategies in industrial relationsIndustrial Relations Journal, 1985
- Managing Labour Relations through the RecessionEmployee Relations, 1985
- Industrial Relations and the British Economy, 1979–1983Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society, 1984
- Shop stewards through expansion and recessionIndustrial Relations Journal, 1983
- Case and Situation AnalysisSociological Review, 1983