Validation of a computer based system for assessing dietary intake.
- 8 August 1987
- Vol. 295 (6594) , 369-372
- https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.295.6594.369
Abstract
Dietary intake was assessed in 50 patients in hospital by using a dietary history method and computer based system for data collection and standard food tables to calculate the composition of nutrients. The results were compared with those from a weighed assessment that was calculated by using both food tables and manufacturers' food analyses. The use of the food tables overestimated mean (SEM) individual nutrient intakes by between 2.5% (1.5%) and 15.5% (3.0%). The mean errors associated with the dietary history assessment varied from -23% (7.8%) for fat intake to +21.4% (8.5%) for carbohydrate intake. Overall, 30% of the assessments of total nutrient intakes that were calculated using this method were within -20% to +20% of actual values; 18% were within -10% to +10%. The mean errors associated with the computer based assessment varied from -1.0% (4.3%) for carbohydrate intake to +8.5% (3.4%) for protein intake. Overall, 56% of the assessments of total nutrient intakes were within -20% to +20% of actual intakes; 31% were within -10% to +10%. The computer based system provides an accurate, reproducible, convenient, and inexpensive method for assessing dietary intake.This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Within- and between-person variation in dietary surveys: number of days needed to classify individuals.1986
- FOOTNOTES TO FOOD TABLES .1. DIFFERENCES IN NUTRIENT INTAKES OF DIETITIANS AS CALCULATED FROM THE DHSS FOOD TABLES AND THE 4TH EDITION OF MCCANCE AND WIDDOWSON THE COMPOSITION OF FOODS1985
- Food intake measurement: problems and approachesThe American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1983
- Surface electrochemistry of iron porphyrins and iron on tin oxide electrodesAnalytical Chemistry, 1977
- Validity of the 24-hr. recall. Analysis of data obtained from elderly subjects.1976
- Individual Dietary Surveys: Purposes and MethodsPublished by S. Karger AG ,1971
- A Computer-Based Medical-History SystemNew England Journal of Medicine, 1966
- A Comparison of Dietary Study Methods. I. Dietary History vs. Seven-Day-RecordJournal of the American Dietetic Association, 1952
- FOOD TABLES: THEIR SCOPE AND LIMITATIONSThe Lancet, 1943