Lifetime broadening in bulk photoemission spectroscopy

Abstract
We establish, theoretically and experimentally, that the ‘‘anomalous’’ broadening of features in photoemission spectra close to the Fermi energy, reported by Hwu et al. [Phys. Rev. B 45, 5438 (1992)] is readily understood, by standard theory, as due to final-state broadening. Although we agree with the authors’ statement that ‘‘anomalous’’ broadening is not sufficient as evidence for non-Fermi-liquid behavior, we do not endorse the claim that their results are qualitatively similar to previous results for surface bands.