Abstract
In the previous work (Tanaka 1983), the linear stability problem of surface gravity waves on deep water to ‘superharmonic’ disturbances was investigated. The result obtained there suggested that the waves lose stability at the steepness which corresponds to the maximum total energy and the impulse. This result, however, apparently contradicts other work and thus the validity of it has been regarded as questionable. In the present paper, the validity of our previous result is first confirmed by two independent methods. Then, it is also shown that the contradictions with other works will disappear in a natural way when the explicit form of the unstable disturbance around the critical steepness is appropriately taken into account.

This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit: