Mass discrimination during MC-ICPMS isotopic ratio measurements: Investigation by means of synthetic isotopic mixtures (IRMM-007 series) and application to the calibration of natural-like zinc materials (including IRMM-3702 and IRMM-651)

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
A long known way of anchoring isotope ratio values to the SI system is by means of gravimetrically prepared isotopic mixtures. Thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS) is the traditionally associated measurement technique, but multi-collector double focusing inductively coupled plasma (MC-ICP)-MS now appears to be an attractive alternative. This absolute calibration strategy necessitates that mass discrimination effects remain invariant in time and across the range of isotope ratios measured. It is not the case with MC-ICPMS and the present work illustrates, in the case of Zn isotopic measurements carried out using locally produced synthetic Zn isotope mixtures (IRMM-007 series), how this calibration strategy must be adjusted. First, variation in mass discrimination effects across the measurement sequence is propagated as an uncertainty component. Second, linear proportionality during each individual measurement between normalized mass discrimination and the average mass of the isotope ratios is used to evaluate mass discrimination for the ratios involving low abundance isotopes. Third, linear proportionality between mass discrimination and the logarithm of the isotope ratio values for n(67Zn)/n(64Zn) and n(68Zn)/n(64Zn) in the mixtures is used iteratively to evaluate mass discrimination for the same ratios in the isotopically enriched materials. Fourth, ratios in natural-like materials (including IRMM-3702 and IRMM-651) are calibrated by external bracketing using the isotopic mixtures. The relative expanded uncertainty (k = 2) estimated for n(68Zn)/n(64Zn) and n(67Zn)/n(64Zn) ratio values in the synthetic isotopic mixtures and the natural-like zinc samples was in the range of 0.034 to 0.048%. The uncertainty on the weighing (0.01%, k = 1) was the largest contributor to these budgets. The agreement between these results and those obtained with a single detector TIMS and with another MC-ICPMS further validated this work. The absolute isotope ratio values found for IRMM-3702—material also proposed as “delta 0” for δ-scale isotopic measurements—are n(66Zn)/n(64Zn) = 0.56397 (30), n(67Zn)/n(64Zn) = 0.082166 (35), n(68Zn)/n(64Zn) = 0.37519 (16), and n(70Zn)/n(64Zn) = 0.012418 (23). The derived Zn atomic weight value Ar(Zn) = 65.37777 (22) differs significantly from the current IUPAC value by Chang et al. [1]. Remeasurement, with isotopic mixtures from the IRMM-007 series, of the Zn isotope ratios in the same Chang et al. [1] material have revealed large systematic differences (1.35 (27)% per atomic mass unit) that suggest unrecognized measurement biases in their results.