Multivariate Discrimination of Colorado PlateauGilaspp.: The “Art of Seeing Well” Revisited

Abstract
Fishery managers have long been troubled by phenotypic variation within and among Colorado Plateau Gila. The problem is twofold. From an historical perspective, there was reticence to investigate fishes long considered as “undesirable.” In a taxonomic sense, there is confusion over within- and among-species variability. We document the former, then clarify the latter by applying discriminant analysis to meristic and morphometric data collected from museum specimens. We test three hypotheses: roundtail chub G. robusta humpback chub G. cypha and bonytail G. elegans are morphologically indistinguishable; juveniles are assignable to species based upon adult characters; and putative hybrids are morphologically intermediate between parental forms. Through the use of meristic characters in a nonparametric discriminant analysis, over 95% of all adults were segregated to species. By using morphometric characters, 97% could be allocated to species. Gila robusta was easily separated from G. cypha and G. ele...