Maslow, Monkeys and Motivation Theory
- 1 August 1997
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Organization
- Vol. 4 (3) , 355-373
- https://doi.org/10.1177/135050849743004
Abstract
One of the most enduring influences in motivation theory is Maslow's needs hierarchy. The empirical basis for the needs hierarchy was Maslow's own studies of dominance in monkeys and humans. In both cases, Maslow concluded that one individual's ability to be dominant over others was due to that individual's acknowledged superiority, and that differences in human or monkey groups occurred because of differences in the exercise of dominance by the individuals in those groups. The incorporation of these ideas into the needs hierarchy explains its intuitive appeal: the hierarchy justifies managerial power, while at the same time absolving managers of accountability for ineffective motivational practices. However, recent primatological research reveals serious flaws in Maslow's understanding of the nature of dominance in monkeys and apes. As a consequence, Maslow's theory is based on research which is no longer considered valid by the discipline in which it was done.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Feminism, Management and Self‐ActualizationGender, Work & Organization, 1994
- Resistance to Change During RestructuringJournal of Management Inquiry, 1992
- Humanistic Psychology as Liberal Ideology: the Socio-Historical Roots of Maslow's Theory of Self-ActualizationJournal of Humanistic Psychology, 1979
- Animal Sociology and a Natural Economy of the Body Politic, Part I: A Political Physiology of DominanceSigns: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 1978
- Maslow's Other ChildJournal of Humanistic Psychology, 1977
- Dominance-Quality and Social Behavior in Infra-Human PrimatesThe Journal of Social Psychology, 1940
- The social psychology of the vertebrates.Psychological Bulletin, 1939
- Dominance, Personality, and Social Behavior in WomenThe Journal of Social Psychology, 1939
- IX. The Comparative Approach to Social BehaviorSocial Forces, 1937
- Dominance-feeling, behavior, and status.Psychological Review, 1937