AMBIGUITIES IN LOOP QUANTIZATION: AREA VS. ELECTRIC CHARGE

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
In this letter we compare the ambiguity that, as pointed out by Immirzi, arises in the loop quantization of general relativity with a somewhat similar ambiguity in the quantization of Maxwell theory. The "loop" quantization leads to a quantum theory in which the fundamental excitations are loop-like rather than particle-like. Each such loop plays the role of a quantized Faraday's flux line. For the case of Maxwell theory, we show that the quantization depends on an arbitrary choice of a parameter ε that carries the dimension of electric charge. For each value of ε the electric charge that can be contained inside a bounded spatial region is automatically quantized in units of ℏ/ε. The requirement of consistency with the quantization of electric charge observed in our Universe fixes a value of the, so far arbitrary, parameter ε of the theory. We compare the ambiguity in the choice of parameter ε with the β-ambiguity of quantum gravity, and comment on the possible way this ambiguity can be fixed.