Evidence against or for topological defects in the BOOMERanG data?

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
The recently released BOOMERanG data were taken as “contradicting topological defect predictions.” We show that such a statement is partly misleading. Indeed, the presence of a series of acoustic peaks is perfectly compatible with a non-negligible topological defect contribution. In such a mixed perturbation model (inflation and topological defects) for the source of primordial fluctuations, the natural prediction is a slightly lower amplitude for the Doppler peaks, a feature shared by many other purely inflationary models. Thus, for the moment, it seems difficult to rule out these models with the current data.