Early babbling has been characterized as being fundamentally a mandibular oscillation: the infant’s repeated lowering and raising of its mandible yields a perceived contrast between consonants produced in a closed vocal tract configuration and vowels produced with an open tract. We wondered whether babblers produce rhythmic mandibular oscillations without phonation and, if so, whether there might be a relationship between such ‘jaw wags’ and early speech. We report two studies: the first is a longitudinal, observational study of 14 infants, some of whom were hearing and some Deaf. Seven infants (3 hearing, 3 Deaf, and 1 hearing-impaired) produced numerous speech-like, rhythmic jaw wags without phonation; sometimes jaw wags formed a single utterance with phonated babbling. Most jaw wags reported here were produced when these infants were ages 8–13 months. The second study, a survey of 90 parents of 4- to 10-month-old hearing infants, suggests that silent babbles may be a widespread phenomenon of early speech development.