The Problem of Missing Links: Today and Yesterday

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
The problems of "missing links" over the years since Darwin's On the Origin of Species is analyzed in the perspective of our increased knowledge of the fossil record and our changing concepts of evolution, geology, and biology. The history of application of evolutionary theory to the fossil record and the consequences of the conflict of categorical, essential classification and evolutionary continuity are examined, as they relate to the "naive" idea of "missing links". Transitions between taxonomic categories are treated at two levels: the infraspecies-species level, and the supraspecies level. In the latter category case analyses of transitions within and between the major groups of metazoans and metaphytes are made, with special attention to the evidence of origins of groups in the fossil record. Throughout, the impacts on evolutionary theory of changes in knowledge and interpretations of the record of the history of life are considered. The problem of the existence of linkages and phylogenies at the species and generic levels has been much reduced during the last one hundred and twenty years. How this reduction supports or denies Darwin's concepts of phyletic gradualism is still a matter of interpretation of the evidence. At familial and higher levels, the establishment of linkages between categories has been much less successful, and decreasingly so at each successive higher level. Under the very best circumstances, however, morphological and stratigraphically graded transitions between classes and subclasses have been found. At the level of phyla and higher categories, any information on transitions as far as the fossil record is concerned is essentially non-existent. Fairly standard patterns of transitions between high categories can be established on the basis of the optimal cases, and these point up the continuing problems in evolutionary theory as being the interrelationships and integration of micro-evolutionary and macro-evolutionary processes.