New Perspectives on the Clovis vs. Pre-Clovis Controversy
- 1 October 1993
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Antiquity
- Vol. 58 (4) , 626-647
- https://doi.org/10.2307/282199
Abstract
We consider the Clovis vs. pre-Clovis debate from three perspectives: migration models; petroglyph and surface-artifact ages; and scientific method. First, we test the hypothesis that a Clovis migration can account for the temporal and spatial distribution of South American Paleoindian sites “accepted” by Clovis-first advocates. Using a Clovis-first model, site ages are underpredicted by approximately 1,500 years, suggesting that the Clovis hypothesis cannot be reconciled with accepted empirical data. Second, we present North American accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS)14C minimum-limiting ages from petroglyphs and surface artifacts that demonstrate continued support for a pre-Clovis occupation of the dryland west, as well as a Beringian entry into the hemisphere. Third, the debate has been confounded by a widespread misstatement of the problem. Though Clovis occupation is a “solved” issue, the competing hypotheses are whether the first migration was Clovis or pre-Clovis; the presence of Clovis sites is simply a necessary prediction of both migration theories. The empirical implications of the Clovis-first hypothesis are virtually untested. Scientifically evaluating the first peopling controversy requires scrutinizing the empirical test implications and logical coherency of both competing hypotheses.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Global Changes During the Last 3 Million Years: Climatic Controls and Biotic ResponsesAnnual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 1992
- New Approach to the Radiocarbon Dating of Rock Varnish, with Examples from DrylandsAnnals of the American Association of Geographers, 1992
- A framework for interpreting paleoclimatic variations in Eastern BeringiaQuaternary International, 1991
- Coming into the Country: Early Paleoindian Hunting and MobilityAmerican Antiquity, 1988
- Rock art chronology in eastern CaliforniaWorld Archaeology, 1987
- Clovis Origin UpdateKIVA, 1987
- Dramatic founder effects in Amerindian mitochondrial DNAsAmerican Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1985
- Stable Carbon Isotope Ratios of Rock Varnish Organic Matter: A New Paleoenvironmental IndicatorScience, 1985
- Demographic ArchaeologyPublished by Elsevier ,1981
- Some Population Problems Involving Pleistocene ManCold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology, 1957