Hysterectomy: variations in rates across small areas and across physicians' practices.

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
This analysis focuses on the practice of hysterectomy across 33 hospital catchment areas of 1 Canadian province, using claims data from the Manitoba health insurance system. Hysterectomy rates varied 5-fold across hospital areas. The availability of hospitals and physicians was unrelated to area rates, and there appeared to be no access barriers in the low-rate areas. High-rate areas were characterized by women who visited large numbers of differnt physicians and by having larger proportions of French, Polish and Italian residents (ethnic groups which are largely Catholic in Manitoba). Although women residents of high rate areas made somewhat more visits for gynecologic problems and had many more D and C (dilation and curretage of the uterus), this may be due as much to the practice style of physicians treating patients from these areas as to gynecologic need. Residents of high and medium-high rate areas are more likely to have hysterectomy-prone surgeons as their primary physicians. Such physicians appear both more likely to label their patients; conditons as gynecologic in origin and more likely to advise surgical intervention (both D and C and hysterectomy) once such conditions are diagnosed. Thus, a combination of patient and physician characteristics may explain much of the variation in small area hysterectomy rates, rather than narrowly defined medical need.

This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit: