Does pre‐vocational education work?
- 1 October 1990
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Research Papers in Education
- Vol. 5 (3) , 183-201
- https://doi.org/10.1080/0267152900050301
Abstract
Whether pre‐vocational education improves young people's prospects in the labour market and whether it should have a place in the school curriculum at all have been at the centre of a long‐standing debate in education. This study supplements data from the ESRC 16‐19 Initiative to address these questions. In the core study of the 16‐19 Initiative, over three and a half thousand young people in two cohorts (aged 15–16 and 17‐18) selected from school records in three British towns, Swindon, Sheffield and Liverpool, were followed up with annual questionnaire enquiries for two years. The schools they attended were contacted about their vocational education policies, and classified in terms of vocational emphasis. Analysis of the data relating curriculum emphasis to labour‐market outcomes showed that the most vocationally oriented schools were catering for the early leavers and that boys were benefiting marginally in getting full‐time jobs at 16 years. Curriculum experience differed for these leavers with more exposure to administrative and clerical subjects and computing, but other than a slightly stronger commitment to work, there was no significant difference in their values. The findings are discussed in relation to others from TVEI evaluations and some conclusions are drawn about the place of pre‐vocational education in the 11‐18 curriculum.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Post?16 Education, Training and Employment: Provision and Outcomes in Two Contrasting AreasBritish Journal of Education & Work, 1990
- Education and Training: Provision and Experience∗British Journal of Education & Work, 1990
- Making the Gift Horse Jump the Hurdles: The Impact of the TVEI Pilot on the first Scottish CohortBritish Journal of Education & Work, 1989
- Further education or continuing education? changes towards vocationalising education and training in BritainInternational Journal of Educational Development, 1988
- Job Mobility and the Careers of Young MenPublished by National Bureau of Economic Research ,1988
- The British youth labour market in crisisInternational Review of Applied Economics, 1987
- The Curriculum and the New Vocationalism∗British Journal of Education & Work, 1987
- The early twentieth‐century secondary curriculum debate in EnglandHistory of Education, 1984
- Practical Subjects in mid‐Victorian Elementary Schools.History of Education, 1979