The Revised COMPTEL Orion Results

Open Access
Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
COMPTEL observations of the Orion/Monoceros region have shown distinct evidence for excessive 3-7 MeV emission that was attributed to nuclear de-excitation lines from accelerated 12C and 16O nuclei. Unfortunately, we must conclude now that this appears to be a spurious result. This conclusion follows from a better understanding of the instrumental background, from a better exposure of the region, and from an improved analysis method. We show here how the impact of each of these gradually reduces the signal to a less than 3 σ result. The prime underlying cause seems to be 24Na activation in and around the upper COMPTEL detectors. Combining all available data, we now set a 2 σ flux upper limit on the 3-7 MeV emission of Orion of 3 × 10-5 γ cm-2 s-1, to be compared with the previously derived flux of ~10-4 γ cm-2 s-1.