Space-time orbits for interacting relativistic particles: Syntactic versus semantic observables
- 15 November 1978
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review D
- Vol. 18 (10) , 3617-3623
- https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.18.3617
Abstract
Recent work establishing a violation of the so-called "no-interaction theorem" for interacting relativistic particles was directed primarily toward the development of the quantum theory of such systems. In that work the classical trajectories for two-particle systems span a two-dimensional region in phase space. The present paper addresses itself more directly to the intended classical content of the "no-interaction" theorem, namely, the determination of orbits in space-time for the pair of particles under consideration. The problem is nontrivial in the sense that its treatment requires the recognition of the conceptual distinction between syntactically defined observables and semantically defined observables. The latter betray Machian features in so far as they make reference to the open character of the system vis-a-vis the other matter of the universe. It is noteworthy and curious that such considerations were not required for the proper treatment of the quantized system. A critique of the essential features of the "no-interaction" theorem, including certain unstated (and hard to justify) assumptions, is presented.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Interacting relativistic particlesPhysical Review D, 1978
- A no-interaction theorem in classical relativistic Hamiltonian particle mechanicsIl Nuovo Cimento (1869-1876), 1965
- Interaction contra Classical Relativistic Hamiltonian Particle MechanicsJournal of Mathematical Physics, 1963
- Relativistic Invariance and Hamiltonian Theories of Interacting ParticlesReviews of Modern Physics, 1963
- The Relativistic Dynamics of a System of Particles Interacting at a DistancePhysical Review B, 1952
- On Lorentz invariance in the quantum theoryMathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 1942
- Lorentz-invariance in quantum theoryMathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 1939