Randomized trial of Lichtenstein versus Shouldice hernia repair in general surgical practice
- 1 January 2002
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in British Journal of Surgery
- Vol. 89 (1) , 45-49
- https://doi.org/10.1046/j.0007-1323.2001.01960.x
Abstract
Background: The aim of the present randomized trial was to compare the Shouldice procedure and the Lichtenstein hernia repair with respect to recurrence rate, technical difficulty, convalescence and chronic pain. A further aim was to determine to what extent general surgeons in routine surgical practice were able to reproduce the excellent results reported from specialist hernia centres. Methods: Three hundred patients with primary inguinal hernia were randomized to either a Shouldice repair or to a tension-free Lichtenstein repair. In a pretrial training programme the five participating general surgeons were taught to perform the two techniques in a standard manner. Follow-up was performed after 8 weeks, 1 year and 3 years. The last examination was performed by an independent blinded assessor. Results: There was a significant difference in operating time in favour of the Lichtenstein technique. After a follow-up of 36–77 months seven recurrences were found in the Shouldice group (95 per cent confidence interval (c.i.) 1·3 to 8·1) and one in the mesh group (95 per cent c.i. 0·0 to 2·0). Chronic groin pain was reported by 4·2 and 5·6 per cent in the Shouldice and Lichtenstein groups respectively. It was characterized as mild or moderate in all except two patients who had the Shouldice operation. Conclusion: Lichtenstein hernia repair was easier to learn, took less time and resulted in fewer recurrences. It was possible to achieve excellent results with this technique in a general surgical unit.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- HERNIA REGISTERS AND SPECIALIZATIONSurgical Clinics of North America, 1998
- Methods of repair and risk for reoperation in Swedish hernia surgery from 1992 to 1996British Journal of Surgery, 1998
- Role of the Should ice technique in inguinal hernia repair: A systematic review of controlled trials and a meta-analysisBritish Journal of Surgery, 1996
- Shouldice Inguinal Hernia Repair in the Male AdultAnnals of Surgery, 1995
- Estimating sample sizes for binary, ordered categorical, and continuous outcomes in two group comparisonsBMJ, 1995
- Critical scrutiny of the open “tension-free” hernioplastyThe American Journal of Surgery, 1993
- The tension-free hernioplastyThe American Journal of Surgery, 1989
- Short stay surgery for inguinal hernia: Experience of the Shouldice operation, 1970–1982British Journal of Surgery, 1986
- SURGEON-RELATED VARIABLES AND THE CLINICAL TRIALThe Lancet, 1978
- THE RESULTS OF INGUINAL HERNIA REPAIRSThe Lancet, 1959