Low gene copy number shows that arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi inherit genetically different nuclei

Abstract
‘One genome, one organism’ sounds a reasonable rule of thumb, but for arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF), it may not be the case. These fungi are symbiotic on the roots of most plants, where they improve plant growth. They have existed unchanged for 400 million years, without having sexual reproduction. High genetic variability is seen within single individuals, but the explanation of this phenomenon is a subject of controversy. One hypothesis, that variation within a single cell is due to genetically different nuclei, challenges some basic assumptions of evolutionary genetics. But a new study concludes that the observed variation cannot be explained by polyploidy or high copy number, the alternatives usually offered, and that it is certainly partitioned among the nuclei. This topic is also debated this week in Brief Communications Arising (see panel on page 121). Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) are ancient asexually reproducing organisms that form symbioses with the majority of plant species, improving plant nutrition and promoting plant diversity1,2. Little is known about the evolution or organization of the genomes of any eukaryotic symbiont or ancient asexual organism. Direct evidence shows that one AMF species is heterokaryotic; that is, containing populations of genetically different nuclei3. It has been suggested, however, that the genetic variation passed from generation to generation in AMF is simply due to multiple chromosome sets (that is, high ploidy)4. Here we show that previously documented genetic variation in Pol-like sequences, which are passed from generation to generation, cannot be due to either high ploidy or repeated gene duplications. Our results provide the clearest evidence so far for substantial genetic differences among nuclei in AMF. We also show that even AMF with a very large nuclear DNA content are haploid. An underlying principle of evolutionary theory is that an individual passes on one or half of its genome to each of its progeny. The coexistence of a population of many genomes in AMF and their transfer to subsequent generations, therefore, has far-reaching consequences for understanding genome evolution.