Differences in Access and Quality of Care across HMO Types
- 1 March 1991
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Health Services Management Research
- Vol. 4 (1) , 32-45
- https://doi.org/10.1177/095148489100400105
Abstract
This paper investigates differences between various HMO types (eg, staff model, group model, IPA model) in their access and quality of care outcomes. Several sources of evidence are analyzed, including research findings reported in the health administration literature, survey data from a random sample of 42 HMOs, and accreditation data gathered from 26 HMOs in four states. Consistent with previous research, both the random sample survey data and the accreditation data indicate that group and staff model HMOs score more favorably than IPA models in terms of the level of services provided, preventive care, and various quality of care outcomes. Data from the random sample survey indicate that IPA models score more favorably on measures of patient satisfaction and access outcomes. These findings are consistent with speculation that IPAs trade off utilization and quality controls for patient access and physician autonomy. Contrary to speculation, the effect of HMO type on access and quality may be independent of the degree to which physicians are financially and organizationally tied to the HMO.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- The New Structure of Individual Practice AssociationsJournal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 1987
- Comparative Aspects of Medical Practice Organizational Setting and Financial Arrangements in Four Delivery SystemsMedical Care, 1984
- The Performance of Health Maintenance Organizations: An Analytic ReviewThe Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly. Health and Society, 1980
- Use of Hospital Services Under Two Prepaid PlansMedical Care, 1980
- Mental Health Services: Utilization by Low Income Enrollees in a Prepaid Group Practice Plan and in an Independent Practice PlanMedical Care, 1979
- Rates of Surgical Care in Prepaid Group Practices and the Independent Setting What Are the Reasons for the Differences?Medical Care, 1979
- Assessing the Quality of Care for Urinary Tract Infection in Office Practice A Comparative Organizational StudyMedical Care, 1978
- Expectations and Experience of HMO Enrollees after One YearMedical Care, 1978
- Health concern, HMO enrollment, and preventive care useJournal of Community Health, 1977
- The Organization of Medical Practice and Practice Orientations Among Physicians in Prepaid and Nonprepaid Primary Care SettingsMedical Care, 1975