Are systematic variations in thrust belt style related to plate boundary processes? (The western Alps versus the Carpathians)

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
Within the Mediterranean region, Cenozoic deformation of the Western Alps and the West to East Carpathians has resulted in two different styles of foreland fold and thrust belt. The most prominent difference between the two belts is the presence (Carpathians) or absence (Western Alps) of contemporaneous back‐arc extension, but other important differences in structure, topography and metamorphism also exist. These differences in thrust belt style developed mainly during the final stages of thrust belt evolution and appear to reflect fundamental differences in the tectonic settings of the Western Alps and the Carpathians in middle and late Cenozoic time. In particular, they appear to be the result of convergence that is in the first case driven primarily by major plate motions and in the second case only by local motions of small lithospheric flakes or fragments. We suggest that the structural styles developed in these two mountain belts may be useful in identifying mountain belts that have evolved in similar tectonic settings elsewhere in the world. In this respect, the Western Alps and the Carpathians can be regarded as typical examples of two different styles of foreland fold and thrust belt (or more properly as end‐member examples within a broad spectrum of foreland fold and thrust belt styles). We propose that continental subduction zones and orogenic belts can be loosely divided into segments that show no major back‐arc extensional deformation adjacent to the belt (the Western Alps) and segments that exhibit back‐arc extension contemporaneously with thrusting (the Carpathians). The former are found in areas where the rate of overall plate convergence exceeds the rate of subduction, and are commonly typified by extensive involvement of crystalline basement in thrusting, exposure of high grade metamorphic rocks at the surface, high topographic elevation, and large amounts of erosion (tens of kilometers). The latter are found in areas where the rate of subduction exceeds the rate of overall plate convergence and are commonly typified by thrust belts with little to no involvement of crystalline basement in thrusting, low grade to no metamorphism, low topographic elevation, little erosion and, in some instances, an anomalously deep foredeep basin system.