Kuhn, Lakatos, and the History of Economic Thought
- 1 March 1987
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in International Journal of Social Economics
- Vol. 14 (3/4/5) , 118-131
- https://doi.org/10.1108/eb014052
Abstract
This article attempts to tackle a fundamental methodological question in economics. The task is to investigate whether competing traditions in the history of economics are commensurable or not, that is, whether there is a firm ground on which a researcher could adjudicate the truth content of a theory. Thomas Kuhn in philosophy and Donald McClosky in economics among others are understood to advance the thesis that theories are incommensurable since there is no empirical ground to resort to in order to resolve disputes among traditions in economics. Karl Popper in philosophy and Mark Blaug in economics among others argue that theories are commensurable since there is a sharp and distinct criterion which could determine the scientific content of a theory. A more sophisticated version of Popper's falsificationism has been advanced in philosophy by Imre Lakatos and has been correspondingly followed in economics by Spiro Latsis, E. Roy Weintraub and others.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Empirical and Ideological Elements in the Decline of Ricardian EconomicsReview of Radical Political Economics, 1980
- Dialectics and the Evolution of Economic ThoughtHistory of Political Economy, 1973
- Behaviour and the Concept of PreferenceEconomica, 1973
- Situational Determinism in EconomicsThe British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 1972
- The Entropy Law and the Economic ProcessPublished by Harvard University Press ,1971
- On the Structure of Scientific Revolutions in EconomicsHistory of Political Economy, 1971
- Does Economics Have a Useful Past?History of Political Economy, 1969
- Criticism of Ricardian Views on Value and Distribution in the British Periodicals, 1820–1850History of Political Economy, 1969
- IS THERE A ?STRUCTURE OF SCIENTIFIC REVOLUTIONS? IN ECONOMICS?Kyklos, 1969
- Consumption Theory in Terms of Revealed PreferenceEconomica, 1948