A Critical Study of Molecular Photodissociation and CHON Grain Sources for Cometary C2
Open Access
- 1 August 1997
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Astronomical Society in The Astrophysical Journal
- Vol. 484 (2) , 879-890
- https://doi.org/10.1086/304349
Abstract
The spatial distribution of C2 in the very inner comae of comets (4 km) often shows a profile which is flatter than can be reproduced by standard two-generation models. Because of this it has been suspected that a source other than the typical two-generation photodissociation is responsible. Previous investigators have suggested that either grains, most likely CHON grains, or a three-generation photodissociation may the source for cometary C2. We have performed an analysis of a set of spatial profiles of C2 in comet P/Halley to investigate this question. A three-generation dissociation model that unlike previous attempts can include the ejection velocity of daughter fragments at each dissociation is compared with published results of a purely radial three-generation model. We find that the addition of ejection velocities has a similar effect on three-generation models as has been shown already in two-generations by the vectoral and Monte Carlo models. Specifically, the addition of typical ejection velocities which are usually on the order of 1 km s-1 for a heavy species essentially fills in the "hole" in the inner coma which would otherwise be left by three-generation models that are purely radial, yielding profiles that are not easily distinguishable from two-generation model (Haser, vectorial, or Monte Carlo). We have also constructed a CHON Grain Halo (CGH) model that also produces flat inner profiles. The inferred size of the CGH is 88,000 km at 1 AU. This is consistent with some estimates of the depletion of small grains in comet Halley but is much larger than the extended source for H2CO and CO (~104 km). The strict r2 variation for the heliocentric distance dependence for the C2 source is better explained by a direct CGH source. A combination of either grandparent-parent molecule scale lengths or grandparent CHON grains and an intermediate molecule would yield parent scale length variations closer to r1.5 (more like CN and NH2) than r2 which is found for C2.Keywords
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- A survey of 39 comets using CCD spectroscopyThe Astrophysical Journal, 1996
- Shells in the C2 Coma of Comet P/HalleyIcarus, 1995
- The Nature of the Source of CO in Comet P/HalleyIcarus, 1994
- The trend of production rates with heliocentric distance for comet P/HalleyThe Astrophysical Journal, 1994
- P/Halley - Effects of time-dependent production rates on spatial emission profilesThe Astrophysical Journal, 1993
- Comet P/Halley - Spatial distributions and scale lengths for C2, CN, NH2, and H2OThe Astrophysical Journal, 1991
- Periodic variations in the activity of Comet P/Halley during the 1985/1986 apparitionThe Astronomical Journal, 1990
- Discovery of organic grains in comet HalleyNature, 1986
- Dust and neutral gas modeling of the inner atmospheres of cometsReviews of Geophysics, 1986
- Spectrophotometry of 17 comets. I - The emission featuresThe Astronomical Journal, 1984