Collective Action and the Fallacy of the Liberal Fallacy
- 1 January 1981
- journal article
- Published by Project MUSE in World Politics
- Vol. 33 (2) , 178-196
- https://doi.org/10.2307/2010369
Abstract
The problem of whether the rational, self-interested individual will voluntarily subscribe to a large group providing collective benefits is examined, using the perspectives of Hardin's application of game theory and Olson's application of economic theory. The arguments in each case are held to be unsatisfactory, and the same analysis cannot automatically be applied to all problems involving collective action. The subscription to large groups normally represents a distinct sub-class of problems, the solution to which, contrary to the established wisdom, is that the rational, self-interested individual with a net benefit (together, perhaps, with the irrational one with a net loss) will voluntarily subscribe to a group providing a collective good.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Collective action as an agreeable n-prisoners' dilemmaBehavioral Science, 1971
- An Exchange Theory of Interest GroupsMidwest Journal of Political Science, 1969
- Interest Groups in Comparative AnalysisThe Journal of Politics, 1961
- Systematic Political Theory: Observations on the Group ApproachAmerican Political Science Review, 1960
- Systematic Political Theory: Observations on the Group ApproachAmerican Political Science Review, 1960
- A Group Basis of Politics: A New Name for an Ancient MythThe Western Political Quarterly, 1958