A Bayesian method for the synthesis of evidence from qualitative and quantitative reports: The example of antiretroviral medication adherence
- 1 October 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 14 (4) , 226-233
- https://doi.org/10.1258/jhsrp.2009.008186
Abstract
Objectives: Bayesian meta-analysis is a frequently cited but very little-used method for synthesizing qualitative and quantitative research findings. The only example published to date used qualitative data to generate an informative prior probability and quantitative data to generate the likelihood. We developed a method to incorporate both qualitative and quantitative evidence in the likelihood in a Bayesian synthesis of evidence about the relationship between regimen complexity and medication adherence. Methods: Data were from 11 qualitative and six quantitative studies. We updated two different non-informative prior distributions with qualitative and quantitative findings to find the posterior distribution for the probabilities that a more complex regimen was associated with lower adherence and that a less complex regimen was associated with greater adherence. Results: The posterior mode for the qualitative findings regarding more complex regimen and lesser adherence (using the uniform prior with Jeffreys’ prior yielding highly similar estimates) was 0.588 (95% credible set limits 0.519, 0.663) and for the quantitative findings was 0.224 (0.203, 0.245); due to non-overlapping credible sets, we did not combine them. The posterior mode for the qualitative findings regarding less complex regimen and greater adherence was 0.288 (0.214, 0.441) and for the quantitative findings was 0.272 (0.118, 0.437); the combined estimate was 0.299 (0.267, 0.334). Conclusions: The utility of Bayesian methods for synthesizing qualitative and quantitative research findings at the participant level may depend on the nature of the relationship being synthesized and on how well the findings are represented in the individual reports.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Transforming Verbal Counts in Reports of Qualitative Descriptive Studies Into NumbersWestern Journal of Nursing Research, 2009
- Using qualitative metasummary to synthesize qualitative and quantitative descriptive findingsResearch in Nursing & Health, 2007
- A multitude of syntheses: a comparison of five approaches from diverse policy fieldsEvidence & Policy, 2006
- Changes in Attitudes Toward Antiviral Medication: A Comparison of Women Living with HIV/AIDS in the Pre-HAART and HAART ErasAIDS and Behavior, 2005
- Sleep Disturbance and Depression as Barriers to AdherenceClinical Nursing Research, 2005
- Medication adherence for HIV positive women caring for children: in their own wordsAIDS Care, 2004
- Factors that Influence Adherence to HIV Medications: Perceptions of Women and Health Care ProvidersJournal of the Association of Nurses in AIDS Care, 2003
- Adherence to Antiretroviral Therapy and Its Association with Sexual Behavior in a National Sample of Women with Human Immunodeficiency VirusClinical Infectious Diseases, 2002
- Barriers to antiretroviral medication adherence in HIV-infected womenAIDS Care, 2000
- The Modified Gauss-Newton Method for the Fitting of Non-Linear Regression Functions by Least SquaresTechnometrics, 1961