The Cochrane Lecture. The best and the enemy of the good: randomised controlled trials, uncertainty, and assessing the role of patient choice in medical decision making.
- 1 February 1994
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health
- Vol. 48 (1) , 6-15
- https://doi.org/10.1136/jech.48.1.6
Abstract
This lecture aimed to create a bridge to span the conceptual and ideological gap between randomised controlled trials and systematic observational comparisons and to reduce unwanted and unproductive polarisation. The argument, simply put, is that since randomisation alone eliminates the selection effect of therapeutic decision making, anything short of randomisation to attribute cause to consequent outcome is a waste of time. If observational comparison does have any significant part in evaluating medical outcomes, there is a grave danger of "the best", to paraphrase Voltaire, becoming "the enemy of the good". The first section aims to emphasise the advantages of randomised controlled trials. Then the nature of an essential precondition--medical uncertainty--is discussed in terms of its extent and effect. Next, the role of patient choice in medical decision making is considered, both when outcomes can safely be attributed to treatment choice and when they cannot. There may be many important situations in which choice itself affects outcome and this could mean that random comparisons give biased estimates of true therapeutic effects. In the penultimate section, the implications of this possibility both for randomised controlled trials and for outcome research is pursued and lastly there are some simple recommendations for reliable outcome research.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Patient preferences and randomised clinical trials.BMJ, 1989
- Mortality and Reoperation after Open and Transurethral Resection of the Prostate for Benign Prostatic HyperplasiaNew England Journal of Medicine, 1989
- The Pathophysiology of Urinary Incontinence among Institutionalized Elderly PersonsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1989
- Current problems and future challenges in randomized clinical trials.Circulation, 1984
- Will Payment Based on Diagnosis-Related Groups Control Hospital Costs?New England Journal of Medicine, 1984
- Compliance with disulfiram treatment of alcoholismJournal of Chronic Diseases, 1983
- Oral antibiotic prophylaxis in patients with cancer: A double-blind randomized placebo-controlled trialThe Journal of Pediatrics, 1983
- Small-Area Variations in the Use of Common Surgical Procedures: An International Comparison of New England, England, and NorwayNew England Journal of Medicine, 1982
- Professional uncertainty and the problem of supplier-induced demandSocial Science & Medicine, 1982
- Small Area Variations in Health Care DeliveryScience, 1973