The Relative Value of Empirical Evidence
- 1 December 1979
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Family Process
- Vol. 18 (4) , 427-441
- https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1545-5300.1979.00427.x
Abstract
Arguments between adherents of different therapeutic models are often based on the assumption that empirical evidence is ultimately the judge of the merits of the respective approaches. The gathering of empirical evidence, however, is programmed by epistemological premises that in turn are not tested by "objective" demonstration but rather by their congruence with prevailing sociocultural values. The epistemological premises behind indivdual- and systems-oriented models are incompatible, and respectively congruent with currently coexistent and opposite sociocultural values. Adherence to a particular model is thus based on epistemological-axiological positions rather than neutral objective evaluation.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Psychosomatic FamiliesPublished by Harvard University Press ,1978
- Behavioral Marriage Therapy: II. Empirical PerspectiveFamily Process, 1978
- Behavioral Marriage Therapy. III. The Contents of Gurman et al. May Be Hazardous to Our HealthFamily Process, 1978
- Behavioral Marriage Therapy: I. A Psychodynamic‐Systems Analysis and CritiqueFamily Process, 1978
- Behavioral Marriage Therapy. IV. Take Two Aspirin and Call Us in the MorningFamily Process, 1978
- Family Therapy Training for Paraprofessionals in a Community Mental Health CenterFamily Process, 1977
- Families and Family TherapyPublished by Harvard University Press ,1974
- Strategies of psychotherapy.Published by American Psychological Association (APA) ,1963