A study of networks simulation efficiency: fluid simulation vs. packet-level simulation

Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
Network performance evaluation through traditional packet-level simulation is becoming increasingly difficult as today's networks grow in scale along many dimensions. As a consequence, fluid simulation has been proposed to cope with the size and complexity of such systems. This study focuses on analyzing and comparing the relative efficiencies of fluid simulation and packet-level simulation for several network scenarios. We use the "simulation event" rate to measure the computational effort of the simulators and show that this measure is both adequate and accurate. For some scenarios, we derive analytical results for the simulation event rate and identify the major factors that contribute to the simulation event rate. Among these factors, the "ripple effect" is very important since it can significantly increase the fluid simulation event rate. For a tandem queueing system, we identify the boundary condition to establish regions where one simulation paradigm is more efficient than the other. Flow aggregation is considered as a technique to reduce the impact of the "ripple effect" in fluid simulation. We also show that WFQ scheduling discipline can limit the "ripple effect", making fluid simulation particularly well suited for WFQ models. Our results show that tradeoffs between parameters of a network model determines the most efficient simulation approach.

This publication has 5 references indexed in Scilit: