Computational comparison of quantum-mechanical models for multistep direct reactions

We have carried out a computational comparison of all existing quantum-mechanical models for multistep direct (MSD) reactions. The various MSD models, including the so-called Feshbach-Kerman-Koonin, Tamura-Udagawa-Lenske and Nishioka-Yoshida-Weidenmüller models, have been implemented in a single computer system. All model calculations thus use the same set of parameters and the same numerical techniques; only one adjustable parameter is employed. The computational results have been compared with experimental energy spectra and angular distributions for several nuclear reactions, namely, ${}_{}{}^{90}{}_{}{}^{}\mathrm{Zr}$(p,p’) at 80 MeV, ${}_{}{}^{209}{}_{}{}^{}\mathrm{Bi}$(p,p’) at 62 MeV, and ${}_{}{}^{93}{}_{}{}^{}\mathrm{Nb}$(n,n’) at 25.7 MeV. In addition, the results have been compared with the Kalbach systematics and with semiclassical exciton model calculations. All quantum MSD models provide a good fit to the experimental data. In addition, they reproduce the systematics very well and are clearly better than semiclassical model calculations. We furthermore show that the calculated predictions do not differ very strongly between the various quantum MSD models, leading to the conclusion that the simplest MSD model (the Feshbach-Kerman-Koonin model) is adequate for the analysis of experimental data.