Criticism: Ephemeral and enduring
- 1 January 1974
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Speech Teacher
- Vol. 23 (1) , 9-14
- https://doi.org/10.1080/03634527409378050
Abstract
Rhetorical criticism performs two relatively distinct functions. Social criticism evaluates the means used and the ends advocated in contemporary rhetoric in order to raise issues and encourage public discussion. As such, it is ephemeral—linked to particular issues, times, and circumstances. “Academic” criticism attempts to discover and explicate the processes of human symbolization and, as such, makes enduring contributions to rhetorical theory. Standard definitions of critical objects and objectives obscure these distinctions and are partially responsible for our failure to produce a significant number of practicing critics.'Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Conventional wisdom—traditional form—the presidents message of November 3, 1969Quarterly Journal of Speech, 1972
- The second personaQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1970
- The problem of judgment and effect in historical criticism: A proposed solutionWestern Speech, 1969
- Method in rhetorical criticismThe Southern Speech Journal, 1969
- The anatomy of critical discourseSpeech Monographs, 1968
- Archetypal metaphor in rhetoric: The light‐dark familyQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1967
- The functions of rhetorical criticismQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1956
- The rhetoric of historical movementsQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1952
- Public address: A study in social and intellectual historyQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1947
- The perils of rhetorical criticismQuarterly Journal of Speech, 1944