“I Know One When I See One” — Differentiating LD and Non-LD Students
- 1 February 1984
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Learning Disability Quarterly
- Vol. 7 (1) , 89-101
- https://doi.org/10.2307/1510265
Abstract
This study examined the extent to which school personnel were able to differentiate learning disabled students from low achievers by examining patterns of scores on psychometric measures. Subjects were 65 school psychologists, 38 special education teachers, and a “naive” group of 21 university students enrolled in programs unrelated to education or psychology. Provided with forms containing information on 41 test or subtest scores of 9 school-identified LD students and 9 non-LD students, judges were instructed to indicate which students they believed were learning disabled and which were non-learning disabled. Accuracy and inter-judge agreement confirmed the difficulty of differentially diagnosing students with learning disabilities suggesting that having information from a battery of tests does not increase the decision maker's ability to discriminate between LD and non-LD students. Considering the extreme difficulty of integrating empirical and non-empirical information, it is recommended that current assessment practices be simplified.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identifying children with learning disabilities: When is a discrepancy severe?Journal of School Psychology, 1982
- Similarities and Differences Between Low Achievers and Students Classified Learning DisabledThe Journal of Special Education, 1982
- Toward Defining Discrepancies for Specific Learning Disabilities: An Analysis and AlternativesLearning Disability Quarterly, 1979
- Perspectives on Assessment of Learning Disabled StudentsLearning Disability Quarterly, 1979
- Educable Mentally Retarded, Learning Disabled, Emotionally Disturbed: Similarities and DifferencesExceptional Children, 1979
- Diagnostic Test Pattern Differences among LD, ED, EMH, and Multi-Handicapped StudentsThe Journal of Educational Research, 1978
- Labels, Categories, Behaviors: Ed, Ld, and Emr ReconsideredThe Journal of Special Education, 1977
- Positive Reinforcers for Modification of Auditory Processing Skills in LD and EMR ChildrenJournal of Learning Disabilities, 1975
- Learning Disability and Emotional Disturbance: Factors Relating to Differential DiagnosisExceptional Children, 1973
- Overconfidence in case-study judgments.Journal of Consulting Psychology, 1965