THE EVOLUTION OF STRATEGY VARIATION: WILL AN ESS EVOLVE?
- 1 January 2005
- journal article
- Published by The Society for the Study of Evolution in Evolution
- Vol. 59 (6) , 1183-93
- https://doi.org/10.1554/04-447
Abstract
Evolutionarily stable strategy (ESS) models are widely viewed as predicting the strategy of an individual that when monomorphic or nearly so prevents a mutant with any other strategy from entering the population. In fact, the prediction of some of these models is ambiguous when the predicted strategy is "mixed", as in the case of a sex ratio, which may be regarded as a mixture of the subtraits "produce a daughter" and "produce a son." Some models predict only that such a mixture be manifested by the population as a whole, that is, as an "evolutionarily stable state"; consequently, strategy monomorphism or polymorphism is consistent with the prediction. The hawk-dove game and the sex-ratio game in a panmictic population are models that make such a "degenerate" prediction. We show here that the incorporation of population finiteness into degenerate models has effects for and against the evolution of a monomorphism (an ESS) that are of equal order in the population size, so that no one effect can be said to predominate. Therefore, we used Monte Carlo simulations to determine the probability that a finite population evolves to an ESS as opposed to a polymorphism. We show that the probability that an ESS will evolve is generally much less than has been reported and that this probability depends on the population size, the type of competition among individuals, and the number of and distribution of strategies in the initial population. We also demonstrate how the strength of natural selection on strategies can increase as population size decreases. This inverse dependency underscores the incorrectness of Fisher's and Wright's assumption that there is just one qualitative relationship between population size and the intensity of natural selection.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- On the Evolution of Behavioral Heterogeneity in Individuals and PopulationsBiology & Philosophy, 1998
- On the instability of evolutionary stable strategiesBiosystems, 1997
- Multilocus Evolutionarily Stable Strategy Models: Additive EffectsJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1997
- Evolutionary Stable Strategies: A review of basic theoryTheoretical Population Biology, 1987
- HIERARCHICAL SELECTION THEORY AND SEX RATIOS. II. ON APPLYING THE THEORY, AND A TEST WITH FIG WASPSEvolution, 1985
- Mutations, perturbations and evolutionarily stable strategiesJournal of Applied Probability, 1982
- Strategy stability in complex populationsJournal of Applied Probability, 1980
- Evolutionarily stable nesting strategy in a digger waspJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1979
- A Biometrics Invited Paper. Genetic Equilibrium under SelectionPublished by JSTOR ,1967
- Extraordinary Sex RatiosScience, 1967