Results of the United Kingdom children's cancer study group's malignant germ cell tumor studies

Open Access
Publisher Website
Google Scholar
Abstract
The United Kingdom Children's Cancer Study Group's malignant germ cell tumor studies were undertaken to establish standard protocols for investigating, staging, and treating children, and to study the efficacy of new drug combinations and the value of serial measurement of serum alphafetoprotein (AFP) and human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG). Boys with Stage I testicular tumors were treated by orchidectomy alone, whereas, after appropriate surgery, chemotherapy was recommended for children with more advanced testicular tumors or with tumors at other sites. From 1979 to 1987, 126 children aged 0 to younger than 16 years with malignant germ cell tumors were registered. They were similar to patients in other large pediatric series with respect to sites of origin, age at presentation in relationship to primary site, histology, female predominence for sacrococcygeal site, and presence of associated malformations (present in 17%). Serum AFP was measured in 123 patients and was elevated in 115, whereas HCG was raised in 19 of 77. Monitoring by serial AFP measurement proved valuable in assessing response to therapy and in early detection of tumor recurrence. When treatment results were assessed in February 1988, 101 of 122 patients were alive (four who received nonprotocol chemotherapy were excluded). Forty‐four patients had been cured by surgery alone (41 with testicular tumors, two with ovarian tumors, and one with sacrococcygeal tumor). All of the remaining 78 children received chemotherapy. The initial low dose vincristine, actinomycin, and cyclophosphamide (LDVAC) regimen proved ineffective, actuarial survival at 5 years follow‐up being 8% (12 patients), and a regimen of cisplatin, vinblastine, and bleomycin (PVB) caused unacceptable toxicity, with actuarial survival at 5 years follow‐up being 67% (nine patients). Five‐year actuarial survival was 87% for 17 children given high dose VAC with or without doxorubicin and 84% for 33 given bleomycin, etoposide, and cisplatin (BEP). All 7 children given various combinations of these regimens survived. Excluding the 12 LDVAC cases, patient survival by site was as follows: testis (59 patients, 100%); vagina, uterus, and prostate (four patients, 100%); ovary (25 patients, 88%); thorax (five patients, 40%), and other (four patients, 67%). Similarly, patient survival by stage was Stage I (62,97%), Stage II (14,86%); Stage III(18,83%); and Stage IV (16,72%). Survival by histology was analysed only in cases for which histologic review had been done the LDVAC cases were excluded. Survival was 99% for 68 patients with yolk sac tumors, 75% for eight patients with immature teratomas, 70% for 11 patients with mixed tumors, and 50% for four patients with germinomas. There was no relationship between outcome and initial AFP level or between outcome and the level of HCG.